raaj khandelwal

Gadgets
Home | Amazon Shopping | doodle | About Me | Cool Links | Funny Images | My Images | Cool Space | Funny Quotations | Funny Jokes | Gadgets | Projects | Contact Me | Comments

watch out for latest gadgets and reviews 

 
General features
  • Announced in 2005
  • GSM900/1800/1900
  • Battery type Li-Ion
  • Battery life:
    • talk mode up to 8.5 hours
    • standby mode up to400 hours
  • Graphical display, shows up to 262000 colours and has the resolution of 176x220 pixels (TFT). The display may hold up to7 text lines, 2 service lines and 1 line with icons.
  • 1.3 MP camera, flash
  • Java (MIDP 2.0), Mascot Capsule 3D Micro Engine
  • Stereoloudspeakers
  • Style-Up panels
  • Dimensions: 93 x 46.5 x 22.5 mm
  • Weight: 128 gramms

w550.jpeg
www.raajkhandel.tripod.com

Memory
  • Phonebook memory for 510 numbers + SIM memory. For a name you can keep up to 6 numbers, e-mail address and other information. You can assign a picture to a name in the phonebook (photo), it will be shown at incoming call.
  • Users' groups
  • Organizer - calendar(up to 300 events), to-do list (up to 80 events)
  • Call log of 30 last calls of all types , you can view separate lists
  • Free memory available for Java applications, photos and other applications about 256 MB

Connectivity

  • WAP 2.0, WAP Push
  • GPRS(4+2)
  • IrDA
  • Bluetooth
  • Mail client(SMTP/POP3)
  • Synchronization with PC
  • SyncML
  • Wirelles Village Instant Messaging
  • Access NetFront HTML browser
  • OMA DRM phase 1

Music handsets comparison – which one to choose?

It’s widely known, that comparisons based off real handsets’ specifications often attract attention of wide audience – though once we get to comparing music phones, one can justly say that all conclusions depend on subjective impressions, as tastes differ. Frequencies measurement does not give plain data, which can help in practice either – how can you judge whether device A is superior to device B when both of them have default earphones plugged in and output sound is almost of the same quality? It seems under these conditions such issues are pointless and not worth posting.

However there is something that saves the day – so called focus-groups, which arrive at a conclusion by testing music playback quality and overall feeling of every given device subjectively. These experiments allow obtaining information that are likely to prove useful in practice, and predicting attitude towards the product once it is released. Not a single magazine provided test of this kind, thus Mobile-Review.com has managed to hit the status of pioneer once again. I should stress that in most cases focus-groups are organized by manufacturers themselves, nevertheless they don’t completely fulfill their main objective – rating a device fairly, and pretty often those results turn out to be biased. Before putting our hands on the very experimental results, let’s see which models have undergone our tests.

Comparison participants or the modern market of music handsets

The very concept of music handsets has been developed since Sony Ericsson in cooperation with Sony reanimated the Walkman brand. And the truth of the matter is that this was the first great success of a music phone on the entire market. Simultaneous updates of the rest of the lime-up and presence of other high profile music solutions didn’t affect the sale rates much. It was Sony Ericsson to start the trend of positioning music part as essential in the first place. However this manufacturer couldn’t create enough of handicap to ensure its leadership for a long period – Motorola was also grinding in this field, and this resulted in ROKR line-up launch, which’s first representative E1 was a re-designed Motorola E398 with iTunes support. The model proved to be such a big failure in 2005, that we won’t even include it in the range of compared phones, it’s an outmoded device in many ways. A bit later on, Nokia also joined the race for taking over the music phones market – and this attempt was rather successful, as Nokia N91 announcement made all brand loyal people to greatly anticipate this one. Though, since the device has not appeared on the market yet, we won’t review its capacity here. The second reason for doing so, that this model is positioned as a solution residing in the high-price bracket and has a hard drive incorporated. Comparison with Samsung i300, Sony Ericsson W950, Sony Ericsson P990i would make sense for sure – basically this article is more likely to be written in the near future. This issue doesn’t feature very promising model Alcatel S853 simply because we didn’t manage to get one while the focus-group was working, even now we failed to find this device in retail stores.

This article reviews not all the introduced handsets, but also those, which are only closing in to their release dates – this group consists of another model in ROKR product line, Motorola E2; Nokia 3250, even though it’s a youth smartphone, the manufacturer positions it as a music phone. Naturally, the pioneer of this field, Sony Ericsson, has its representatives in this issue as well - Sony Ericsson W800i, Sony Ericsson W810i, Sony Ericsson W900i. All results, acquired for Sony Ericsson W800i are true for Sony Ericsson K750i as well – all you need to do is to update firmware, earphones from the standard kit and plug in a bigger memory card. (not the best way considering minimal difference in prices, though there are still some people who are fond of challenges).

We didn’t include any models, which have a media player onboard though are not aimed at the market we are currently reviewing. The major specifications of all music handsets released in 2006 are as follows (from our point of view):

  • Presence of a 3.5 jack, possibility of using own earphones
  • Hot swap of memory card, type of memory card doesn’t matter
  • Support of playlists, special functions, equalizers

For example model Nokia 6230i may be used for playing back music, though until the very recent times it had lacked a 3.5 mm jack with Fast Port. Apart from that, the 6230i isn’t positioned as a music solution. Now you have a hint about which devices are excluded from this review – such handsets often appear quite attractive for consumers, who require music capabilities only as an addition, rather than a key function. Therefore here we are going to cover devices, initially aimed at the other part of the audience. Theoretically, that is the reason why Siemens S75 and similar solutions left the field, further more, their users still have problems with playing back MP3 files on early firmware versions. Nonetheless, in order to show what the difference between high profile music phones and solutions of that kind is, we decided to let S75 in. Unfortunately most of Samsung models don’t hold a 3.5 mm jack on their casings, and thus are not featured in this very issue, though taking into consideration their similarity, we felt we needed to include one - Samsung X700.

  • Motorola ROKR E2
  • Nokia 3250
  • Samsung X700
  • Siemens S75
  • Sony Ericsson W800i
  • Sony Ericsson W810i (almost the same as Sony Ericsson W300i)
  • Sony Ericsson W900i

Comparing – what to and how to?

First things first – we are going to rank music capabilities of the devices, ergonomics, sizes etc. Outlook and design are not rated here for being a very subjective thing and, besides, all the information found in the review is a guide to action on no account. In the second place we will see how good the rest of functions are materialized in the phones – from phonebooks to pre-installed games. The conclusion sums up all the specifications plus the music functions, so those who agree giving up some music capacity in order to get the other one in a better condition – skip all the parts until you see the conclusion. Each function is rated from 1 to 5 points, though it’s comparative rather than absolute – in fact, we are not attempting to rank this or that parameter as compared to the other models, but state, that, say, the handsets with the better quality of equalizers get 5 points, those with slightly worse ones – 4 etc. The next thing we do is summarizing all the results, and the final sum appears on your display. No doubt, the total is compared to model’s price, and thus we get price/quality ratio, which strongly affects final standings, where favorites may end up as outsiders.

The focus group was involved in comparing music capabilities, so each test, carried out with the help of our focus group is market with FG abbreviation. The users were offered the following information (exactly in the way it’s written here):

The music part includes these specifications:

  • Measurements, design and weight
  • Memory cards extension slot, type, maximum capacity, price per 1 Mb
  • Synchronization with PC, music upload, additional software
  • General media player’s concept
  • Additional media player’s features – expansion of stereo-base, equalizers, original technologies for making sound quality better
  • Supported music files formats
  • 3.5 mm jack, headset quality
  • Quality of earphones shipped with a phone – type and reliability
  • External control keys, remote control
  • Bluetooth stereo-headsets, presence of A2DP profile
  • FM-radio availability, its quality
  • Handset’s life time with network part tuned off under conditions of constant music playback.

All other characteristics are not considered in this issue, even though they are not of the less importance, like display quality, phonebook quality and so on – here we are reviewing exactly music capabilities of the phones.

So happens, that Walkman line-up by Sony Ericsson doesn’t provide any handsets with youth design, that’s why they can’t claim only youth audience. The first phone in this range, W800i possess white-orange trim, which made some to refuse purchasing the handset, and on the other hand appealed to a certain share of consumers. Why talking about that? Because only this model may be hardly considered as a solution for youth, at the same time both Nokia 3250 and Motorola ROKR E2 have been presented as handsets targeted at younger audience in the first place. All other participants of this survey relate to a class of phones aimed to appeal a wider audience.

Model Weight, grams Measurements, mm
Motorola ROKR E2 117 102х46.5х18
Nokia 3250 115 103.8х50х19.8
Samsung X700 95 108x43.7x19.4
Siemens S75 99 103x47x18.5
Sony Ericsson W800i 104 100х46х20.5
Sony Ericsson W810i 99 100х46х19.5
Sony Ericsson W900i 148 109х49х24
Sony Ericsson W300i 94 90х47х24.5

As you see, all models may be divided into two camps – those with weight over 100 grams and less than this value. Sony Ericsson W900i stands out against this background, as it features maximum weight, and consequently, measurements. Even though the W800i could have been moved to the first group, we decided not to do it for the sake of justice. From this it follows that we have the following groups of devices:

  1. Samsung X700, Siemens S75, Sony Ericsson W810i, Sony Ericsson W300i
    2. Sony Ericsson W800i, Motorola ROKR E2, Nokia 3250
    3. Sony Ericsson W900i

The manufacturers are making efforts to keep the applied memory cards type the same throughout the entire product line, though there are several outstanding models as well. For example in most of its products Motorola uses MicroSD cards, while ROKR E2 is equipped with a standard SD extension slot. Sony Ericsson has recently stepped in the period of global technologies upgrade, that’s the reason why we see it switching from MS Duo Pro to more compact M2. The former type is not so widespread on the market, but the company ensures that by the time the first handset, supporting this standard, arrives in the markets, these memory cards will have already hit the shelves of retail stores. At that they stress that the price for M2 will be equal to MS Duo Pro cards with the capacity.

In the column featuring maximum capacity we stated not overall technical possibilities for various standards, but the capacity which will be available in 2006. As of M2 memory cards, their shipment start is scheduled for end of summer – beginning of fall.

Model Memory card Hotswap Maximum size, Gb Memory card found in the kit, Mb
Motorola ROKR E2
SD
+ 2 Gb 128
Nokia 3250 MicroSD /TransFlash + 1 Gb 512
Samsung X700 MicroSD /TransFlash + 1 Gb -
Siemens S75 RS-MMC + 1 Gb 128
Sony Ericsson W800i MS Duo Pro + 4 Gb 512
Sony Ericsson W810i MS Duo Pro + 4 Gb 512
Sony Ericsson W900i MS Duo Pro + 4 Gb 64 (470 Mb of internal memory)
Sony Ericsson W300i MS M2 +/- (need to take off the cover) 1 GB 256

Price for various memory cards is different and directly depends on the given region – in Asia, for example, they cost much less than in Europe. We calculate prices starting from the available products in retail stores at present or forecasts. Cards with the biggest capacity serve as a basis for the calculation, so you should keep in mind that for less capable memory cards price per 1 Mb will be higher.

Memory card type Price per Mb in USD
MicroSD/TransFlash 0.1
SD 0.04
RS-MMC 0.12
MS Duo Pro 0.08
MS M2 0.11

In terms of price/quality ratio the obvious leader is SD format – the maximum size of 2 Gb can be purchased by the majority of consumers. Both Memory Stick Duo Pro and microSD reside in pretty much the same price bracket; even though until recently the price for Sony cards was considerably higher. As you can see, RS-MMC and MS M2 are not going to hit the top of consumers’ interests; by the way, the former format hasn’t been introduced into the market yet. The difference is huge only when opposing SD against all other formats, as for the other specifications, all those cards are rather equal.

  1. Motorola ROKR E2
  2. Samsung X700, Siemens S75, Sony Ericsson W810i, Sony Ericsson W300i, Sony Ericsson W800i, , Nokia 3250, Sony Ericsson W900i

1.3 Synchronization with PC, music upload, additional software

For a music phone, well-realized synchronization with PC may come in handy and earn a handset several points in consumers’ opinion. All the reviewed handsets provide possibility of sending data directly to memory card by putting it in a desktop (if you have a corresponding slot of course), apart from this one can use USB-cable in order to upload some music.

Following a good tradition, Nokia packs Nokia PC Suite in the standard kit – this software kit includes an application for transferring music to a handset with the possibility of conversion of MP3 files into ACC format. Cable’s type – original DKE-2, which is included in the package of Nokia 3250.

Motorola as always offers Mobile Phone Tools – on the whole capabilities of this application are common with no distinguishable differences.

Sony Ericsson provides PC Suite along with its phones – using the program you can explore handset’s memory, memory card’s folders once USB-cable is plugged in. Another utility is Disc2Phone, allowing copying music CDs to a handset, which are converted on air – the application sets up ID3 tags by connecting to CDDB database without any efforts from your side. At present no alternatives of Disc2Phone are available from other manufacturers.

As to Siemens, it arms its users with Mobile Phone Tools tool kit, though it has more disadvantages rather then positive sides: first of all, it’s unstable, hard to install on systems with non-standard hardware configuration. So in case you actually made it work, you will discover functions for transferring files and all other core possibilities. This application reminds of Nokia’s one in many respects.

Samsung prefers applying Easy Studio, a software kit, guaranteeing medium-scaled possibilities and nothing more, as it doesn’t offer any specialized music functions.

Among all these handsets only Samsung X700 is shipped without a USB cable, while the other have it packed into the box. For Motorola ROKR E2 USB-cable is a default miniUSB (B) one.

Model USB cable in the kit USB Mass Storage Software for syncing/music
Motorola ROKR E2 + + +/-
Nokia 3250 + + +/+ (autumn Windows Media Player 11)
Samsung X700 - - +/-
Siemens S75 + - +/-
Sony Ericsson W800i + + +/+
Sony Ericsson W810i + + +/+
Sony Ericsson W900i + + +/+
Sony Ericsson W300i + + +/+

One can say without any doubts, that the handsets by Sony Ericsson are adapted for operating with music files more than the other ones – potentially comparable capabilities are embedded in Nokia 3250, which will only evolve wit the release of Windows Media Player 11. In April’s shipments no extra capabilities regarding synchronization will be provided.

Capacities of Siemens S75, Samsung X700 look quite unattractive against such background, as they are not supposed to work primarily with music and what is more, Samsung doesn’t have a cable in the standard kit.

  1. 1. Nokia 3250 and all Sony Ericsson’s products
  2. Siemens S75, ROKR E2
  3. Samsung X700

1.4 General media player’s concept and special effects

In all of the reviewed cases, media players support creation of playlists and displaying tracks’ info, taken from files’ tags. While working in background mode, all handsets, saving for Samsung’s models and Siemens S75, show information on the current playing song and its position in playlist. Also on incoming call, playback is paused and continued from the moment it was paused at when conversation is ended. As for major drawbacks of Siemens’s device is impossibility of adding to a playlist tracks, located in different folders, also the handset’s media player lacks random playback, sorting by artist, album, etc. – in other words all functions, the other reviewed phones, with the exception of Samsung, are equipped with.

Click here to earn millions of Rupees in 1 minute

rajendrasharma.tk

email rkhandel@rajendrasharma.tk.